Old Bay Potato Salad

  • Prep Time
    10 minutes
  • Cook Time
    15 minutes
  • Serving
    4
  • View
    289

New Orleans probably has more great home cooks per capita than any other city in the country.  The checkout girl at Langenstein’s asked me what I intended to do with my portabella mushrooms and after I told her I was making a sauce for steak, she said she often does an all vegetable ‘crab boil,’ minus the crab, of course.  According to her, mushrooms soak up the spices beautifully and they pair deliciously with boiled corn and potatoes.  Sounds terrific!  A few days later, I was making potato salad, and I remembered that conversation.  I boiled little red potatoes in Old Bay Seasoning, combined them with mayo and mustard, etc., and really it was the best potato salad I’ve ever made.  I can’t stress enough how important it is to take your time and pay attention to every component of every dish you make.  In this potato salad, the potatoes were boiled to the perfect degree of doneness, not overcooked to mush.  A good way to test whether your potatoes are ready is to slice one in half and scrape the flesh with a fork.  You want a potato that holds some shape but has a fluffy interior.  Then: focus on your boiled eggs!  For God’s sake, don’t cook those eggs until they have a green ring around the yolk. That’s the single reason I won’t eat at a certain restaurant around the corner.  If they are willing to serve overcooked boiled eggs on their crabmeat salad, then what the Hell else is going on in that kitchen. If you make the mistake of overcooking your eggs, start over.  I can usually get pale yellow yolks and easily peeled shells by bringing them to a gentle boil, turning off the heat and covering the pot for 10 minutes.  Drain them and run cold water over them immediately to stop the cooking.  Mash the yolks into some mayo before adding that mixture to the salad, then add more mayo to get the consistency you like.  Lastly, don’t be afraid of SALT.  If you are relatively healthy, salt is not going to put you in a coma.  Salt and taste.  Salt and taste.  Taste as you go.  Why would you serve anything to someone you love if you aren’t sure it tastes good?  This deceptively simple potato salad requires attention and care.  Didn’t your mother tell you that anything worth doing is worth doing right?

Ingredients

    Directions

    Step 1

    Boil the new potatoes: Put the potatoes in the water In a big pot over medium high heat. Add a few TBS. of Old Bay Seasoning. Bring the water to a boil. Let the potatoes cook in a healthy boil until done. Test for doneness by taking out a potato and slicing it in half. Scrape the flesh with a fork and when it is soft enough to be mashed but still fluffy the potatoes are done. This should take about 10 minutes. Drain and cool. Peel them as best you can (leaving a little peel is okay). Cut them in half.

    Step 2

    Boil the eggs. Do not overcook (see above). Peel them and cut them in half.

    Step 3

    Mix the egg yolk with some mayonnaise. With a fork, combine the yolk and mayo until you have a thick 'paste.' (I tossed out the egg whites).

    Step 4

    Now, put the chopped red onions in the bottom of a bowl. Add the halved potatoes. Add the chopped pickles. Add the mayo-yolk mixture. Then add some more mayo until you have the consistency you want. Add the mustard. Salt to taste. Combine. This tastes so great when the potatoes are warm, but of course you can chill it in the frig and serve cold too.

    You May Also Like

    Leave a Review

    Your email address will not be published.

    X